“Wait, he doesn’t hit me. So what exactly do I want?” Many women quietly ask themselves this question, sometimes for years. From the outside everything looks fine: a home, children, a routine. Inside there is loneliness, frustration, and an exhaustion that has no name.
Chava Shmilovitch is the founder of Soul Therapy, a Torah-based approach to emotional healing. An emotional and marriage guide, she has accompanied women and couples for 25 years. She devoted an entire conference to this topic. In this article we’ve gathered the main points: what a relationship that isn’t good for you looks like, the signs of an unhealthy marriage, and the first step you can take today.
What Is a Relationship That Isn’t Good for You?
When we talk about abuse in a marriage, most of us think of hitting, shouting, and threats. Those are fairly easy to recognize. But there is another situation that is quieter and no less painful. This is how Chava describes it:
“It’s this quiet kind of thing… it’s no less hurtful, and it’s much harder to recognize.”
, Chava Shmilovitch
A relationship that isn’t good for you is one in which you suffer over a long period and feel that something inside you is slowly being destroyed, even if you can’t point to a single incident. Chava compares it to a churban, a destruction. It isn’t one dramatic moment. It is ongoing damage to parts of who you are.
Some people call this a “toxic relationship,” “emotional abuse in marriage,” or “emotional mistreatment.” Others search online for “narcissistic husband.” Chava avoids labels and long-distance diagnoses. She focuses on what is actually happening: the patterns that keep repeating, the ongoing suffering, and the confusion.
It’s important to say this clearly: not every difficult marriage is an unhealthy one. Some difficulties can be worked through with couples guidance, personal growth work, tefillah (prayer), and growing together. Chava emphasizes that even challenges like ADHD, anxiety, or depression can be addressed, and a good marriage can still be built. The question is whether the difficulty can be healed, or whether this is a situation where one partner’s efforts simply aren’t enough. The goal here is, Heaven forbid, not to break up homes. The goal is to help you grow within your marriage rather than suffer in it.
First of All: What Does a Healthy Marriage Look Like?
To recognize what’s missing, it helps to know what should be there. According to Chava, a good marriage has:
Real friendship, mutual respect, and enjoyment of your time together.
Appreciation and affection instead of constant criticism.
Disagreements that don’t escalate, and problem-solving as partners.
Intimate knowledge of each other: he knows what you love, what you fear, and what you dream about.
Trust, and a sense that he is “on your side.”
A willingness to see your point of view and take it into account.
Mutual empathy: your pain matters to him.
A feeling that you matter to him and that you are growing together.
Signs of an Unhealthy Marriage: What You Feel Inside
The first signs aren’t always in his behavior. Often they show up in your own experience. These are the feelings Chava hears again and again from the women she guides:
Loneliness in your marriage. You’re married, and yet you’re alone. There’s no one to share with, and no one who sees you.
Ongoing frustration. You learn, you work on yourself, you improve, and nothing moves. In a healthy marriage, your growth also changes how you’re treated. Here it doesn’t.
A dead end and helplessness. A sense that there’s no way out and nothing to do but wait.
Loss of strength and hope. The relationship drains all your energy, and there’s none left to grow in other areas of life.
Worn-down self-confidence. Little by little, you start to doubt yourself, your feelings, and your judgment.
A crisis of emunah (faith). The question “Why did You put me in this reality?” follows you even into your prayers.
Feeling invisible. Your needs aren’t seen, and your feelings don’t count.
Constant pressure and alertness. You have to report where you are, rush home, and weigh every word.
Over-responsibility. The whole burden is on you: the home, the children, and the relationship itself.
Chava points out that the body pays a price too. Ongoing stress doesn’t stay only in the soul, and many women describe a situation in which they “can’t afford to get sick.”
What Do You See in Him? Patterns That Repeat
Chava lists several traits that show up again and again in a husband in a relationship that isn’t good for his wife. None of them alone is a diagnosis. But when many of them appear together over time, it’s a sign to stop and take a closer look:
Rigidity, and difficulty being flexible or accepting another opinion.
Lack of empathy: your pain doesn’t touch him, and sometimes there is complete indifference.
Self-centeredness. In Chava’s words, “he is the most important person to himself,” and you don’t come first.
Not taking responsibility, and blaming others, usually you.
Manipulation, dishonesty, and promises that aren’t kept.
He’s always right, and in every argument he turns himself into the victim.
Black-and-white thinking, outbursts, and drama.
Treating you as someone whose purpose is to serve his needs.
Chava describes a situation in which the safe framework of marriage itself becomes a tool for exploitation. It’s as if the husband tells himself, “I’m married, it says so on my ID card, so I can do whatever I want.” Instead of bringing the two of you closer and uniting you, the marriage becomes a cover. She calls this a missing “relationship muscle”: the basic ability to be in a real relationship.
The Cycle of Self-Blame: “If I Just Improve a Little More”
One of the hardest traps is the loop: “It must be my fault, so I’ll improve. I’ll respect him more, be more attentive, more sensitive.” And nothing changes. What’s left is exhaustion, emptiness, and helplessness, and this can go on for many years.
Here Chava brings the words of Duties of the Heart (Chovot HaLevavot, Gate of Submission, chapter 2), which distinguishes between true humility and “weakness of the soul.” Weakness of the soul describes a person who endures harm she could have removed, because she doesn’t recognize her own worth. As Chava explains it, in your life this means: you aren’t aware enough of how important you are, how worthy you are, and how much good you deserve, and so you give up on your own needs.
Hashem did not intend you for a life of suffering. You deserve to experience a relationship that is good and meaningful.
The Most Important Question: Who Takes Responsibility?
So how do you tell the difference between a difficult marriage that can be repaired and one that isn’t good for you? According to Chava, the critical question is whether he is willing to take responsibility and work on things, or whether you are the only one taking responsibility. When you open up to him about what’s hard for you, does he understand what you’re talking about? Is he able to say, “Wait, I’m wrong here, I need to fix this”?
“If you are the only one who has to take responsibility for this marriage, then know that you are not in a marriage.”
, Chava Shmilovitch
When a husband realizes there’s a problem, he usually begins working on himself: he seeks professional help, asks for support, and tries to improve. When this doesn’t happen over a long period, you are left alone inside the relationship.
What Can You Do? First Steps
The decision whether to stay or leave isn’t made from an article, or even from a conference. It is a decision that needs professional guidance. But there are a few steps Chava recommends for every woman who recognizes herself in these descriptions:
Step One: Come Out of Shame and Hiding
Tell people close to you, and open yourself up to support. “It’s not your fault, it’s not because of you, you don’t need to be ashamed.” Above all, don’t say “I’ll manage on my own.” Women in relationships like these are often “superwomen” who carry everything alone, and that is exactly why they need support.
Step Two: Find Out What You’re Dealing With
You can’t diagnose this on your own. An assessment by a professional will give you a clear picture: what you’re facing, how serious it is, and what you can expect. He may refuse to come, and in most cases he does. Even so, a conversation between you and an experienced professional, in which you describe the patterns and the history, can give you an initial direction and take you out of uncertainty. You are fully entitled to ask for this. You deserve to know what you are living with.
Step Three: Change the Direction of Your Efforts
Until now, all your energy has gone toward him: helping him, healing him, praying for him to change. Chava suggests turning that around. See yourself, listen to your own needs, and have compassion for yourself before you have compassion for others. Your salvation won’t come from him. It is within you. Take the strength you’ve invested in changing him and invest it in changing yourself.
Step Four: Set Boundaries
All of us have a passive place inside that sees the situation as a decree from Heaven that nothing can be done about. The work is to balance that place: to set boundaries, to refuse to accept everything that hurts you, and to stop cooperating with manipulation. This is something you learn to do with guidance, step by step.
Step Five: Don’t Stay Alone with the Fear
Fear, for example that he will punish you or take revenge, can keep a woman in a relationship for years. Chava says it plainly: if you feel trapped, and you’re afraid to talk with him or with others, that is the clearest sign that you must reach out for outside help and not stay alone.
If you fear for your safety or your children’s safety, don’t wait.
In immediate danger in Israel: Police, 100. For advice and help with domestic violence: the Welfare Ministry hotline, 118. The call is free.
Step Six: Remember the Children Too
Many women stay because they think, “I’ll suffer, as long as the children are okay.” Chava reminds us that this is an illusion: just as you are suffering, the children are suffering too. Caring for your own soul is also caring for them.
“Hashem Sees You”
Chava closed the conference with the words of the Baal Shem Tov on the emunah of the Exodus from Egypt. In every generation and in every situation, Hashem sees each and every woman and brings her out of everything that weighs on her, in body and in soul. “Truly know that Hashem sees you… He is right there with you.”
And that is where your own work begins: being there for yourself, seeing yourself, paying attention to your feelings, and not waiting for someone else to change before you can live. Even when reality is still hard, you can begin to come out of the loneliness from the inside.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between a difficult marriage and a relationship that isn’t good for me?
In a difficult marriage, both partners can work, seek help, and improve, and the change can be felt. In a relationship that isn’t good for you, only one side takes responsibility, and the suffering continues even when you do everything. According to Chava Shmilovitch, the central question is whether your husband is willing to take responsibility and work on himself.
Can a relationship be harmful even without shouting or violence?
Yes. A relationship that isn’t good for you can be completely quiet: being ignored, criticism, manipulation, lack of empathy, and loneliness within the relationship. It is no less hurtful than physical violence. It is only harder to recognize.
How can I know if my husband is a narcissist?
You can’t diagnose this from an article, and you can’t do it alone. What you can do is notice patterns over time: lack of empathy, self-centeredness, blaming others, and manipulation. A real diagnosis is made by a professional.
What if he refuses to get help?
You can reach out on your own. A conversation with an experienced professional, in which you describe the patterns and the history, can give you an initial direction even without him there. You can also get support and guidance for yourself even if he refuses.
Won’t working on myself be enough to change things?
In a healthy marriage, your growth also changes how you’re treated. In a relationship that isn’t good for you, constant self-improvement on your side alone usually leads to exhaustion and guilt. Working on yourself is very important, but do it out of care for your own soul, not from the illusion that it will change him.
Does recognizing these signs mean I have to leave?
No. The decision whether to stay or leave is personal and complex, and it needs professional guidance. The purpose of all this is to help you recognize your situation, stop blaming yourself, and not stay alone.
If you are in crisis, please reach out to a professional or call ERAN 1201 in Israel.
Keep growing with Chava. Join our free WhatsApp group for short teachings and support: join the free WhatsApp group. And learn about Chiburim, Chava’s year course in Torah-based emotional growth and connection: discover Chiburim.