Invisible Abuse: When Home Stops Feeling Safe, and What Experts Say

Home is supposed to be the place where you take off your armor. The place where you can breathe. But some women come home and that’s exactly where they feel on guard. They listen for footsteps on the stairs, check the tone of his voice, and weigh every word. There are no bruises and nothing to show anyone, and yet home stopped feeling safe a long time ago.

Chava Shmilovitch opened this topic at the second conference in the series “A Marriage That Isn’t Good for You,” on the panel “Living in the Shadow of a Relationship That Isn’t Good for You.” Beside her sat a psychiatrist, psychologists and other professionals who have worked with women in these situations for many years. In this article we have gathered what they said: what invisible abuse is, what it does to body and soul, and what first steps you can take.

What Is Invisible Abuse?

Psychologist Yitzchak Bachar, who spoke at the conference about trauma that comes from an abusive relationship, listed several types of abuse: physical, in the intimate relationship, and financial. Alongside these is another type, which he calls “invisible abuse”: emotional abuse and spiritual abuse.

Why invisible? Because very often, he explained, even the woman going through it doesn’t realize it’s abuse. After the previous conference, women described to him, almost calmly, ongoing situations of insults, blame, manipulation and threats. A woman living with this tends to tell herself, “It’s no big deal, he doesn’t hit me.” His answer is sharp:

“A husband who regularly insults his wife has crossed a red line… This cannot be a normal part of any relationship.”

, Psychologist Yitzchak Bachar, at the conference

Silence as Punishment in Marriage

One example that came up again and again at the conference was punishment through silence. A woman didn’t do something her husband asked, and he stopped speaking to her and ignored her for three months. According to Yitzchak Bachar, this is not rare; it’s something he has heard many, many times over the years. Prolonged silence meant to punish is not “just a mood.” It is part of the picture.

Spiritual Abuse

This may be the hardest part to recognize in a Torah-observant home. Yitzchak Bachar described spiritual abuse as belittling and disparaging a woman’s spiritual worth, presenting her deeds as worthless, undermining her spiritual identity, preventing or limiting her spiritual life, and even trying to force her to transgress mitzvot and act against her conscience. The example he gave: a husband who tells his wife over and over that her tefillah (prayer) is worthless because she doesn’t respect him.

This kind of abuse creates guilt, and it strikes at exactly the place that is supposed to give you strength: your connection with the Creator.

Financial Abuse in Marriage

Control over money also came up at the conference. Yitzchak Bachar described it as an attempt to take exclusive control of resources and create financial dependence. Dr. Muli Grossman, who works with couples and is certified in helping trauma survivors, put it precisely: when he restricts you financially not because there’s no money, but because he is the one who decides and the one in control, that is abuse.

“But He Doesn’t Hit Me”: Why This Is Abuse Too

Dr. Grossman wanted to say this clearly to every woman: emotional, financial and sexual abuse are abuse, and severe abuse. In his words, the mark of a physical blow fades after days, weeks or months; emotional abuse does not fade. And when a woman understands this, she begins to treat herself with more respect, and to take what is happening at home more seriously.

He added a point to think about: in his view, abuse is defined by helplessness. If you live with an ongoing sense of helplessness in the face of what happens at home, perhaps it’s time to stop and gently take a look at what’s going on.

What Happens to Body and Soul When Home Isn’t Safe

Psychiatrist Dr. Shimon Burstein, a clinic director and former deputy director of a rehabilitation hospital, explained that women living in a relationship that isn’t good for them often develop what is called “adjustment disorder”: great, ongoing distress with no end in sight and a feeling of being trapped. Around it develop low mood, nervousness, worries, irritability, trouble sleeping, loss of appetite and less enjoyment of life.

His important message: in most cases this is not an illness but a natural, normal response to ongoing distress. These feelings are the soul’s signal saying, “This situation isn’t good for me, something needs to change.” That’s why he sees talk-based support as the heart of the matter. Medication, in cases where it’s needed, is like crutches: it helps you walk, but it doesn’t replace healing. As long as the distress at home continues, medication alone won’t solve it.

Post-Traumatic Stress from a Relationship

Yitzchak Bachar added that many experts see trauma that comes from a relationship as even more severe than the trauma of war or an accident, because it damages the ability to trust and to be close to someone. In his words, post-traumatic stress is not a flaw or a weakness in the person suffering from it; it is the activation of a survival mode in the soul and the body. The signs he described:

Anxiety, and avoiding situations and people.

Difficulty with closeness and with showing vulnerability.

Trouble sleeping.

A short fuse: reacting strongly to small noises.

Depression and no longer enjoying things that once brought joy.

Difficulty with concentration, motivation and functioning.

Difficulty feeling: “as if we’re behind some kind of glass wall,” as he put it.

He also described a familiar pattern: the woman focuses so much on her husband, just to get a little more quiet until the next time, that she stops noticing her own needs. And when her basic needs for safety, belonging, acceptance and trust are denied again and again, symptoms of post-traumatic stress appear.

Isolation in Marriage: When the Lifelines Are Cut

One of the most powerful images from the conference: our connections with the important people in our lives are like lifelines that nourish us. According to Yitzchak Bachar, it is precisely loneliness and the lack of a support network that make a woman more vulnerable to post-traumatic stress. A husband with narcissistic traits, he explained, wears away at these lifelines: he turns her against her family and presents himself as the only one who truly cares about her. His recommendation: recognize what’s happening, and don’t go along with it.

“This Isn’t Me”: Calling Things by Their Name

Another thing a husband with a personality disorder does, according to Yitzchak Bachar, is try to put a negative identity on his wife and convince her that this is who she is. His practical tool is simple and hard: don’t adopt that identity.

Dr. Ada Michal Weinstein, who spoke at the conference about narcissism, told women that they know on their own whether the relationship is toxic or not; they have first-person authority. Yitzchak Bachar recalled her words: calling things by their precise name is already half the healing, because it lets you understand that “this isn’t me.” Chava Shmilovitch reinforced this: you know the truth, you know what’s right for you, and what you need is support and professional backing that confirm what you feel inside.

Do you recognize yourself in this?

You’re not alone, and what you feel is real.

So What Do You Do? First Steps from the Conference

Recognize it. Notice the patterns: insults, punishing silences, belittling your spiritual life, control over money, isolation.

Don’t buy the identity he puts on you. What is said about you over and over is not necessarily who you are.

Protect your lifelines. Family, friends, a support group: even when it’s hard, try to hold on to them as much as you can.

Get support for yourself. Chava reminded the audience that you are affected too, in body and soul, and that it’s worth saying to yourself honestly: I’ve been through trauma, and maybe I’m still in it. Even after divorce, she said, the effects can last for years, so it’s worth getting support and help.

Consult a professional first, then the rabbi. Chava recommended going to a professional first, and then coming to the rabbi with a full picture of the reality, so that the decision is both halachic and professionally informed.

Come back to these ideas again and again. Chava recommends listening to the conference more than once, because it’s a matter of “the penny dropping,” and it takes time for things to sink in.

Emunah as a Resource, Not a Burden

Yitzchak Bachar said at the conference that our connection with ourselves and with the Creator of the world is not an empty slogan but a real source of healing, and that it’s a mistake to separate the religious world from caring for the soul. And Chava, who has met women afraid that Hashem might be angry with them, said it simply:

“Hashem does not command any woman, ever, to live a life of suffering.”

, Chava Shmilovitch, at the conference

She also suggested a prayer: in the morning blessings, at “Pokeach ivrim” (“who opens the eyes of the blind”), ask to see reality as it is, without pushing it away and without the romantic belief that everything will change by itself.

And What About the Children?

Chava asked women who are suffering not to simply let the situation continue, but to get professional help, and not to think that the children don’t absorb it and aren’t hurt by it. A separate conference in the series is devoted to the topic of children.

If you are afraid for your safety or your children’s safety, don’t stay alone with it:

In immediate danger: call the police.

The Ministry of Welfare’s hotline: 24 hours a day, free of charge, also available on WhatsApp.

Tahel’s crisis line for religious women.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is invisible abuse?

Invisible abuse is harm that leaves no marks: constant insults, blame, threats, silence as punishment, belittling a woman’s spiritual life, and control over money. Psychologist Yitzchak Bachar explained at the conference that it is called invisible because very often even the woman going through it doesn’t recognize it as abuse.

Is punishing silence a form of abuse?

When silence is meant to punish, for example ignoring you for weeks or months because you didn’t do what he asked, the professionals at the conference counted it among the forms of emotional abuse. They said it isn’t rare, and it shouldn’t be dismissed as “a mood.”

What is spiritual abuse?

Belittling a woman’s spiritual worth, presenting her deeds as worthless, limiting her spiritual life, or pressuring her to transgress mitzvot. An example from the conference: a husband who tells his wife over and over that her prayer is worthless. This kind of abuse creates guilt and damages an important source of strength.

Are low mood, anxiety and trouble sleeping a sign that something is wrong with me?

According to psychiatrist Dr. Shimon Burstein, for women living with ongoing distress at home, in most cases these are a natural and normal response, not an illness. They are the soul’s signal that something needs to change. Talk-based support is the main answer, and medication, when needed, is a helping tool.

Does the harm end once the marriage ends?

Not always. Chava Shmilovitch said at the conference that even after divorce the effects can last for many years, so it’s important to get support and help, whether you stay or not.

If you are in crisis, please reach out to a professional or call ERAN 1201 in Israel.

Keep growing with Chava. Join our free WhatsApp group for short teachings and support: join the free WhatsApp group. And learn about Chiburim, Chava’s year course in Torah-based emotional growth and connection: discover Chiburim.

Want to hear more about Chava’s Soul guidance and the Chiburim course?

Join our WhatsApp community for short thoughts, encouragement and updates from Chava, right on your phone.

אתר קורסים מתקדם מבית
 
סקולילנד

התחברות מהירה
באמצעות לינק חד פעמי

שלחו לי לאימייל

התחברות לאתר